Geography: Arizona

Photobucket

What to me is one of the quintessential things about Arizona aside from the Grand Canyon?  Of course the gunfight at the O.K. Corral.  So, I searched long and hard to find a kid appropriate book about it.  Did you know they didn’t even have one at the bookstores in Arizona?  All their stuff in the local interest section was desert, desert, Grand Canyon, desert animals, maybe a book about Kokopelli, but nothing.  I could find the same books in New Mexico and several of them in Texas, so it’s not like it was anything special.

012
So, while I read to them the adventures of the brave hitchhiking possum (shouldn’t it be opossum?  Or is that maybe a Southern thing [imagine the accent when I type that]); they happily played with the toob of Wild West figures I’d found for them.  So they had lots of fun acting out parts of the story, and this worked well because it’s not really a picture book, but one very long story with a couple of pictures to break up the text.

I’d highly recommend picking this up if you see it, I liked the story, and it’s apparently part of a series.  The other benefit is there’s a link (with password) at the back of the book to an audio download.  I haven’t checked it out yet, but I’m intrigued.

This did lead to some interesting conversations.  Things like: “Mommy were the Indians bad guys?”  So, I explained that they weren’t always the bad guys, sometimes they were, and sometimes the cowboys were.  I really think the current trend of blaming everything on the pioneers as these horrible people isn’t healthy.  Yes, there were a lot of mistakes made by them, but there were also mistakes made by the American Indians.  Neither side is blameless.  So, that is what I’m teaching the kids as it’s age appropriate.  Right now, they’re just learning that both sides did things they shouldn’t have.  When they get older we can get into more details, but right now they really don’t need to know more than that.

Okay, off my soap box about history revisionism.  It’s a little bit of a sore subject to me.  I don’t know about other states, but it sure seems like Texas goes through this every time we go through textbook revisions of what history figure are we going to ridicule and who are we going to make into a saint.  Sigh, stupid politicians.

Backing away from the box.  Really, I am now.  Mostly.  Probably for now.  So, to change the subject for more posts about Geography and History head over to Children Grow, Children Explore, Children Learn.

11 thoughts on “Geography: Arizona

  1. I agree with you 100% about history being revised for political correctness. It drives me crazy. I like the way you answered the question posed to you!

  2. When we looked at the Nez Perce battles, that took place around here, we focused on the steps, and mis-steps of both sides – I think it's very American to want to cheer for the underdog – which is usually the Indians, but we have to remember there were two sides of the story.

    If you can't find a book on the O.K. Corral, I think there's an old Star Trek, where Kirk and the crew reenact it 🙂

  3. As Texas goes, so goes the nation when it comes to textbooks. We're not anywhere near Texas and we've heard a lot about it. I watched some of the hearings/negotiation meetings on TV and it was pretty crazy!

    American history isn't pretty at times, that's for sure. This sounds like a great way to explain it to your kids.

  4. Does anyone actually pronounce the 'o' in opossum? Isn't it just a technicality to trip you up in classroom spelling bees? Like the 'o' in MAY-naze?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s